4 min read

Securities litigation: a growing exposure for D&O insurers

Read more

By William Allison & William Naylor

|

Published 18 November 2026

Overview

Claims arising from alleged misstatements in corporate disclosures are now an established feature of the English litigation landscape, with specialist claimant firms, institutional investors and litigation funders increasingly willing to pursue group actions following corporate crises.

This growing trend is a significant concern for corporations, senior managers and their insurers. Allegations involving accounting irregularities, bribery and corruption, sanctions breaches, ESG disclosures and wider governance failings are increasingly common. Claims often target major UK-listed companies and seek damages measured in hundreds of millions, sometimes billions, of pounds. Most settle confidentially, leaving important issues around reliance, causation and loss largely untested by the courts. The result is a claims environment characterised by both severity risk and legal uncertainty.

 

The statutory framework

In broad terms, section 90 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA) creates a statutory cause of action where investors suffer loss as a result of untrue or misleading statements, or omissions, in a prospectus. Section 90A and Schedule 10A address misleading statements, omissions and dishonest delays in other forms of published market information.

Unlike section 90, section 90A claims generally require proof of misconduct at the level of a person discharging managerial responsibility (PDMR), together with reliance, causation and loss.

With the Public Offers and Admissions to Trading Regulations 2024 now in force, the UK has completed its post-Brexit overhaul of prospectus liability. Although the new regime largely reproduces the existing section 90 FSMA framework, it also introduces significant changes, including a safe harbour for forward-looking statements, expanded liability for MTF admission prospectuses (i.e. the disclosure documents which must be published if a when a company lists on a Multilateral Trading Facility, such as AIM), and enhanced sustainability disclosure requirements.

 

The perfect storm for D&O insurers

Securities claims bring together several characteristics that make them particularly challenging from an insurance perspective.

First, the financial stakes can be very high. The Standard Chartered action, which settled in December 2025, pleaded alleged losses of £1.5 billion and involved more than 200 institutional investors representing over 1,000 funds.

Second, securities claims frequently follow regulatory or criminal investigations. Findings by regulators often provide claimants with a platform from which to argue that earlier market disclosures were inaccurate or incomplete. Investigations by the Serious Fraud Office, FCA and overseas regulators have featured prominently in cases.

Third, litigation funding and after-the-event insurance continue to reduce the financial barriers to bringing large shareholder claims, supporting the pursuit of complex and expensive litigation.

Fourth, these disputes are costly to defend. They typically involve extensive disclosure exercises, evidence from current and former directors, and expert evidence on market movements, valuation and loss. Even where claims settle, defence costs can be substantial. In the RBS litigation, reported defence costs exceeded £100 million, separate from the reported settlement of approximately £900 million.

Finally, securities litigation can place considerable pressure on D&O programmes. The same programme may respond to regulatory investigations, claims against directors and officers, and securities claims against the corporate entity. Allocation, aggregation, conduct exclusions, advancement of defence costs, competing insured interests and settlement provisions can all become significant issues.

 

An evolving claims profile

An emerging trend is the use of securities litigation to pursue ESG and governance-related allegations rather than traditional accounting misstatements alone.

Proceedings against Boohoo concern allegedly misleading disclosures relating to working conditions and corporate oversight within its supply chain, demonstrating how statements concerning sustainability, supply-chain governance and modern slavery may form the basis of a section 90A claim following a significant share-price decline.

As companies make public statements regarding sustainability, climate transition plans and supply-chain management, those disclosures will attract greater scrutiny from investors and may become an increasingly important source of future securities claims.

 

Limited judicial authority

A key challenge is the limited judicial guidance available.

The Autonomy litigation is the only section 90A claim to have completed a liability and quantum trial. In July 2025, the High Court awarded more than £646 million plus interest, demonstrating section 90A claims can generate very substantial awards. While the decision provides important judicial guidance, the claim concerned Hewlett-Packard's acquisition of Autonomy and took the unusual form of a "dog-leg" section 90A claim, in which the issuer pursued former directors in respect of its liability to the shareholder claimant. The issues were therefore different from those in a conventional stock-drop claim brought by minority investors.

 

Reliance remains an uncertain legal battleground

In Allianz v Barclays, the High Court held the statutory test required investors or persons influencing the investment decision to show they had read the relevant published information, and claims by passive investors unable to satisfy this test were struck out. By contrast, in the Standard Chartered litigation, the High Court declined to strike out claims brought by passive investors. The case settled before an appellate determination could resolve the issue, leaving uncertainty around 'reliance' in claims by passive investors.

 

Case management trends

The courts adopt case-specific approaches to managing securities litigation which can make case management less predictable. In Boohoo, reliance was directed to be determined at the first trial. In Entain plc, reliance, causation and aspects of limitation were deferred to a second trial, although sample claimants were required to provide disclosure on those issues earlier in the proceedings.

 

Implications for the D&O market

English securities litigation remains some way behind the opt-out class actions seen in the United States, but the foundations for more frequent and increasingly high-value shareholder claims are solid. An established statutory framework, growing investor activism, readily available litigation funding, heightened regulatory scrutiny and expanding corporate disclosure obligations are creating a favourable environment for securities claims.

For D&O insurers, securities litigation is no longer a theoretical risk. It is an emerging exposure capable of generating substantial defence costs, complex coverage issues and significant indemnity payments, particularly as claims become larger, more sophisticated and increasingly coordinated.

Insurers should focus closely on insureds' disclosure controls, governance frameworks, regulatory exposures and corporate culture. Policy wordings also warrant careful scrutiny, particularly in relation to entity securities cover, aggregation, related claims, allocation, conduct exclusions, severability, order of payments provisions and defence costs.

 

This article was first published in Insurance Day.

Authors