5 min read

Can a charity be held responsible when an employee misuses personal data?

Read more

By Tessa Davies & Emma-Jane Dalley

|

Published 20 November 2026

Overview

Note: This article was first published on 6 November 2026 by Charity Finance under the headline 'Vicarious liability for employee actions'.

Charities routinely hold significant volumes of highly sensitive personal data. Whether relating to beneficiaries, donors, volunteers, employees, or service users, access to personal information is often fundamental to delivering charitable objectives.

Recent events in the NHS demonstrate these risks. In June 2026, around 40 hospital staff from Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust were investigated after accessing the records of a three-year-old boy seriously injured in a crocodile enclosure, with the trust referring the matter to the Information Commissioner’s Office. In a separate incident, in September 2026, 10 employees at East Suffolk and North Essex NHS Foundation Trust were removed from duty or suspended following concerns about unauthorised access to a child's medical records after his death.

Incidents of this kind, while tragic, highlight an uncomfortable question for any organisation entrusted with sensitive information: should an employer be held legally responsible when an employee, acting for their own purposes, deliberately misuses access granted in the course of their employment?

A recent High Court decision provides welcome guidance for charities and other organisations grappling with this question.

In JXK and Bamford v The Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police, His Honour Judge Bird considered whether Greater Manchester Police could be held vicariously liable for the actions of a rogue police officer who unlawfully accessed and disclosed personal data.

The officer had accessed police systems without authority, misused personal information relating to the claimants and disclosed that information to third parties. His conduct resulted in criminal convictions for numerous offences under data protection and computer misuse legislation.

The claimants sought damages from the Chief Constable, arguing that the employer should be vicariously liable for the officer's actions. It was accepted that the officer could only access the data because of his employment and that the information was held on police systems. However, it was equally clear that his actions were entirely unauthorised, contrary to his training and undertaken for personal reasons.

The court ruled in favour of the Chief Constable, finding that vicarious liability did not arise in these circumstances.

 

The legal principles

In reaching its decision, the court drew on previous cases, including the Supreme Court's judgment in the Morrison data breach litigation and an earlier Court of Appeal decision involving a local authority employee.

The key question was whether there was a sufficiently close connection between the employee's authorised duties and the wrongful conduct.

The courts have consistently distinguished between:

  • Wrongdoing carried out in the course of an employee's duties
  • Conduct that amounts to a personal venture or "a frolic of their own"

The Supreme Court made clear in the Morrison ruling that employers are not automatically responsible simply because employment provided an opportunity to commit the wrongdoing. The employee's actions must be closely connected to the work they were authorised to perform. Applying those principles, HHJ Bird concluded that the officer's actions were driven by personal motives, were expressly prohibited by his employer and bore no real connection to the role he had been employed to carry out.

The decision will be of particular interest to charities, many of which handle and process sensitive personal information. Those organisations supporting vulnerable adults, children, victims of crime, refugees, individuals experiencing homelessness, and those with health-related needs frequently need to grant staff access to confidential records. The same is true of charities managing donor databases containing financial and personal information.

When that access is misused the consequences can be significant, leading to regulatory scrutiny, reputational damage, and litigation. However, JXK and Bamford provides reassurance that charities will not necessarily be vicariously liable every time an employee deliberately abuses authorised access.

The fact an employee was able to access information because of their role is not enough on its own to establish liability. Where a charity has clear policies, training, and system warnings, and the employee's actions are motivated by personal reasons that fall outside the scope of their role, the courts may be reluctant to impose vicarious liability.

 

Strong controls

That said, the judgment should not be viewed as a complete shield from liability.

Charities remain subject to extensive obligations under UK data protection legislation and are expected to implement appropriate organisational and technical safeguards. A failure to provide adequate training, controls, monitoring, or governance may still expose an organisation to direct liability, even where vicarious liability is ultimately avoided.

The issue of inappropriate access to sensitive records has become increasingly prominent in the health sector, prompting NHS England to issue specific guidance in managing the risks associated with unauthorised access to records. Although directed at NHS organisations, the underlying risks are by no means unique to healthcare. Charities and other organisations entrusted with sensitive personal information may wish to consider whether their own controls, monitoring and response arrangements are sufficiently robust.

The appropriate response will depend on the size and activities of the organisation, but charities should assess whether measures such as the following are in place:

  • Regular data protection training for staff and volunteers
  • Clear acceptable-use and confidentiality policies
  • Role-based access controls limiting access to sensitive records
  • System audit trails and monitoring to identify unusual or unauthorised activity
  • Prompt investigation of suspicious activity
  • Robust incident response and breach reporting procedures to the ICO (and, where appropriate, the Charity Commission)

Documenting these measures can be particularly important when defending claims arising from a rogue employee's conduct. They are also important in the context of safeguarding all those that come into contact with the relevant charity and a demonstration of good governance and risk mitigation procedures. 

 

Key lessons for charities

The judgment in JXK and Bamford reinforces the principle that organisations should not automatically bear responsibility for every deliberate misuse of data by an employee. Following the approach adopted in both Ali and Morrison, the courts have continued to focus on the extent to which the employee's actions were connected to the work they were authorised to carry out.

For charities, the case offers a helpful reminder that strong governance, appropriate training and clear restrictions on data access remain critical, not only in mitigating claims of this type, but protecting the charity and those that come into contract with it.

While no organisation can entirely eliminate the risk of a rogue employee, demonstrating that misconduct was a deliberate departure from clear instructions may prove decisive when responding to legal claims or regulatory scrutiny following unauthorised access to personal data.

Authors