A Collection is a selection of features, articles, comments and opinions on any given theme or topic. It allows you to stay up‑to‑date with what interests you most.
Login here to access your saved articles and followed authors.
We have sent you an email so you can reset your password.
Sorry, we had a problem.
Tags related to this article
Published 22 marzo 2023
Ziaullah & Rapid Vehicle Management Ltd v Zurich Insurance
Judgment was handed down at an application hearing on 08 February 2023 by DDJ Lightman in the County Court at Central London in respect of the defendant's costs which the Judge ordered the CHO to pay in full.
The Judge found that the CHO was providing instructions for the claim instead of the actual claimant and that (a) the costs won at the Trial, and (b) the costs of the application(s) should be paid by them.
Background and issues
The application was made on behalf of the defendant following the successful defence of a Taxi Credit Hire claim brought by the claimant.
At the trial, the claimant did not attend. No witness statement’s had been filed and the List of Documents had been signed by the claimant's Solicitor who confirmed that they had instructions to sign the same from the CHO under CPR 31.10(7), CPR 31.10(9), CPR 31PD 4.4 and 4.7, and CPR PD22 3.6A
The claimant's claim was struck out for failing to file a witness statement and pay the hearing fee. Also at the time, the claimant's Solicitor made an application to come of the record as acting for the claimant which was successful.
The defendant was awarded costs in their favour.
Given that the CHO had instructed the Solicitor to sign the List of Documents we asked that the CHO be added to proceedings to allow us to seek a costs order from them instead of the claimant.
This was granted at the Trial.
A second application for a Third Party Costs Order was made against the CHO after the Trial.
The Judge’s findings
The outcome of this case is a stark reminder to Credit Hire Organisations that if they themselves drive the litigation either with or without a claimant onboard then the Courts are happy to allow defendants to seek their costs directly from them.
For more information or advice, please contact one of our experts in our Vehicle Hire and Damage Team.
+44 (0) 1633 657 798
Rachel Rough, Kathryn Nisbet
Peter Allchorne, Michael McCabe
Peter Allchorne, Caroline Hall, Michael McCabe
Claire Laver, Rhys Pousette, Jemma Lewis, Caroline Bigos
Mark Bailey, Annis Mackay
Emma Fuller, Joanna Folan
Will Potts, Daniel Hobson
Stephanie Welsher, Sarah Ramadan, Katie Jones
William Swift, Louise Gallagher
Kelly Sutherland, Helen Mason