A Collection is a selection of features, articles, comments and opinions on any given theme or topic. It allows you to stay up‑to‑date with what interests you most.
Login here to access your saved articles and followed authors.
We have sent you an email so you can reset your password.
Sorry, we had a problem.
Tags related to this article
Download PDF Print page
Published 29 octubre 2020
Expert determination is a dispute resolution process which can offer a relatively speedy and effective means to settle a dispute: it is generally an appropriate mechanism for resolving technical disputes, such as valuation issues. The dispute resolution clause in a contract between the parties provides the expert with the authority, approach and conditions which they should follow and comply with.
Disputes, when they arise, do not always fall squarely into an expert’s remit – there may be issues regarding how the contract operates, which will affect the manner in which the expert makes their determination. It may not always be appropriate for a technical expert to make binding determinations on such legal issues or, indeed whether they have the jurisdiction to determine the dispute. The dispute resolution clause needs to be interpreted to establish whether it can be read or implied as making the expert the sole arbiter, including in relation to legal questions.
When entering into contracts, parties should think carefully about the types of dispute that they would like a technical expert to determine, to avoid unintentionally reserving contractual interpretation issues to a technical expert, that fall outside their expertise. Conversely, parties may want the expert to have exclusive jurisdiction relating to a specific matter, in which case, this should also be clearly stated. The Courts are now coming down in favour of preserving access to the Courts to determine legal issues, so where a contract does not confer any express rights on an expert in relation to questions of law, parties are likely to retain the right to access the Court to decide such points.
But, why leave the question open? Be clear and concise in the contract about the scope of what a technical expert can decide to avoid arguments at a later date and avoid parties using the forum for a tactical advantage.
London - Walbrook
+44 (0) 20 7894 6495
By Gemma Leonard
By Andrew Morgan, Omotorera Sotinwa
By Sadie Guile
By Clare Hartley, Chloe Postlethwaite
By Emma Gonzalez, Ben Thornycroft
By Anna Hart
By John Dunlop, Omar Asfar
By Sally Morris-Smith
By Nicola Fairbairn
By Anne Harrison, Nadine Kamalaneson
By Clare Hartley, Kai Ricciardiello, Louise Day
By Jonathan Brogden, Millie Bailey
By Karen Howe, Antonio Marino
By David Manifould, Andrew Boulton, Clive Garston, John Dunlop, Michelle Jones, Paul McCartney
By Kai Ricciardiello, Clare Hartley
By Christopher Stanwell
By Christopher Stanwell, Andrew Morgan