D&O in Latin America
Published 25 May 2016
Directors and Officers insurance has been an established line of business in most Latin American territories for many years now. Recent developments have, however, seen an increase in the D&O offering in Latin America and general take up in the market, and the main reasons for this are:
- Increasingly, Latin American companies and their directors and officers are finding themselves exposed to US class actions. Whilst shareholder actions are not as common in Latin America as they are in the US, the US courts have held that where plaintiffs have purchased securities in non-US companies (i.e. American depository receipts) through US stock exchanges, those plaintiffs can pursue the non-US company on US soil. This has lead to US class-actions in the well publicised cases of Petrobras, Braskem, Eletrobras (all from Brazil) and SQM (in Chile).
- There is heightened awareness of the need for enhanced corporate governance standards, and the related exposures, as Latin American countries are increasingly conforming with OECD norms on corporate governance and issues such as money laundering and bribery and corruption.
- There has been a general expansion of international insurers into the Latin America market and the increased availability of capacity has meant that more and more potential buyers are being exposed to these products, although it has perhaps aggravated the already soft market conditions in the region generally (Brazil is perhaps an exception here as we discuss below).
- The last two years in particular have seen an increase in high profile corporate scandals in Latin America, most notably the Petrobras scandal in Brazil.
Latin America is a huge and diverse region, and although certain trends may be identified as being relevant across the region, a knowledge of the individual jurisdictions is invaluable.
D&O in Brazil
The corruption scandals which plague Brazil are of particular interest to the insurance market at the moment. In the last few weeks, not only has the Brazilian president been impeached, but the former president has now come under suspicion and it seems that there are few high profile figures who have not been involved in some way in the Petrobras scandal.
What effect has all of this had on the local D&O market?
On the commercial side, we have seen crimes such as corruption and fraud being excluded from coverage in the local market, as a consequence of corruption scandals such as Mensalao and Lava-Jato.
In view of this, insurance companies have also reviewed their wordings as to defence costs coverage. Fees of defence counsel have escalated as companies seek to hire the most reputable law firms available to represent them. Currently, most D&O policies provide coverage for the advance payment of defence costs, exposing insurers to paying inflated fees with a high risk of not being able to recover those fees.
Many insurers are reviewing their wordings to provide reimbursement only after a final and favourable judgment is given, rather than agreeing to advance payments. Alternatively, insurers are imposing sub-limits on defence costs to avoid excessive legal fees.
The deepening recession in Brazil and the increasing number of companies seeking judicial protection from creditors have also raised the awareness of local underwriters as to the need to assess effective compliance programmes within corporations.
In the circumstances, the local Brazilian market which had been considered 'soft' in the past decade, is gradually turning into a 'hard' market, where insurers are limiting coverage and adopting a more cautious stance in their underwriting style. It remains to be seen whether this will be repeated across the Latin American region.