Banking and finance dispute resolution
For the latest news and comment on banking and finance disputes.
For the latest news and comment on banking and finance disputes.
For all the latest news and comment in clinical negligence healthcare law
This collection looks at the latest news and comment on commercial contracting healthcare law. With the health and social care sector under…
For all the latest news and comment in employment and pensions healthcare law
For all the latest legal and regulatory news and comment in health technology
This collection contains DAC B eachcroft's latest report, The Route to Integrated Healthcare , which provides the first practical examples of how…
This collection looks at the latest strategic, commercial, regulatory and negligence legal and advisory news and comment in health and social care. …
For all the latest news and comment on employment and pensions law.
DAC Beachcroft Dublin specialises in insurance, professional indemnity, defendant personal injury, health, commercial litigation and employment work.…
For all the latest new and comment in tax law.
The GC Collective collection offers insight and comment for General Counsels (GCs) and in-house legal teams.
For the latest news and comment on Corporate, M&A and Equity Capital Markets.
Analysis, commentary and checklists on the legal and governance implications of Brexit on businesses operating in, and trading with, the UK
The Accountant's Liability Collection brings you topical news and insight of interest to accountants, actuaries, trustees and other financial…
Events and online training for the health and social care sector.
DAC Beachcroft's LatAm Quarterly Newsletter discusses topical news and issues in Latin America
In response to client suggestions and requests, DAC Beachcroft's insurance sector flagship publication.
For all the latest legal and regulatory news and comment in health and social care integration
For all the latest news and comment in corporate regulatory healthcare law
Find advice, commentary and thought leadership on all aspects of Director's & Officer's Insurance; from contract formation through to complex…
This collection looks at the latest news, comment and development on the law affecting mental health services. The law affecting mental health…
Our market-leading Information Law team regularly publish articles and updates addressing the ever-evolving Information Law landscape.
This collection looks at our Safety, Health and Environment Team and the products and services they can provide. In the climate of increased…
The Insurance Act 2015 comes into force in August 2016 and will represent a significant change to insurance contract law in this country. This…
Legislative changes are bringing major changes to the Insurance landscape. This collection houses DAC Beachcroft's alerts on the pertinent issues.
For all the latest news and comment in clinical regulatory healthcare law
Organisations face ever-increasing expectations from Government, regulators, customers or service users, and other stakeholders, so scrutiny and…
For all the latest legal and regulatory news and comment in healthcare estates and facilities management
This collection addresses the full spectrum of cyber security and data risk management – the zeitgeist of our age.
We have acted for clients in the majority of significant product liability cases that have been decided in the UK over the last 35 years. Our product…
Considering the future landscapes of our cities
The European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) came into force on 25 May 2016. A rewrite of European data protection law, the GDPR imposes…
Considering the future of housing
For the latest news and comment on public procurement law.
Welcome to the Construction Risks collection. This space is used to report upon issues of interest to those who seek to allocate, manage and reduce…
Technology, brands and intellectual capital are key assets for any successful business. Our intellectual property (IP) team are experts at helping…
Considering the future of retail
The Insurance Market Conditions and Trends report is DAC Beachcroft's insurance sector flagship publication. Now in its tenth year, the report…
The Solicitors' Risk Collection addresses issues and developments affecting legal practitioners, and the professional indemnity insurers of legal…
Published On: 24 June 2016
The UK has voted to leave the European Union. This briefing summarises the likely implications for the insurance market in the UK.
The key point to note is that nothing immediately changes as a result of the referendum result. Indeed, the result does not formally commit the UK to any particular timetable or even to leave the EU at all. This gives the UK some flexibility in its negotiations with the rest of the EU. It also means that how things play out will primarily be a matter of politics rather than law.
That flexibility is lost, however, once the UK gives formal notice, under Article 50 of the Treaty on European Union, of its intention to leave the EU. When that notice is given, the two year process towards an exit, set out in Article 50, begins. Under Article 50, any extension to that two year period requires the unanimous agreement of all other member states. While those two years are intended to give time in which the terms of an exit agreement can be agreed, exit will happen at the end of the two years (assuming member states do not agree an extension) whether an exit agreement is reached or not.
The Leave campaign itself indicated that it had in mind Brexit in 2019; what seems clear is that protracted negotiations will be in no-one's interests.
From a legal perspective, the most significant aspects of an exit agreement are likely to be around the transitional arrangements and the extent to which rights acquired pre-Brexit are preserved.
Exactly what life outside the EU will look like for the UK is unclear. The so-called Norwegian option, of continued access to the EU through membership of the EEA, was largely shunned by the Leave campaign. Certainly, it would not achieve any greater control over immigration from the EU than exists currently. Importantly for the insurance market, however, this option would leave passporting intact.
Any alternative model, be it based on the position currently enjoyed by Switzerland, Turkey or Canada, would be likely to take several years to agree. It would be unlikely, based on any existing precedent, to allow wholesale passporting for UK financial firms into the EU, although some bilateral agreements with individual member states might be achieved. The default position, in the absence of agreement, would be the framework of international agreements largely operating under the auspices of the World Trade Organisation.
It is important to note that the exit agreement referred to above would be negotiated separately from any agreement with the EU about our future relationship. Indeed, a number of European officials have been quoted as saying that the two agreements should not be linked. The period of uncertainty over the UK's long-term relationship with the EU, not to mention the rest of the world, could therefore extend significantly beyond the two to three years it may take to agree the terms of the UK's exit.
There is currently a huge body of UK law that derives from EU law. Dismantling this, and even identifying and agreeing on which aspects should be dismantled, will be an immense task. It will not simply be a case of repealing the European Communities Act 1972, because the many regulations made under the ECA, both in Westminster and in the devolved administrations, will need to be retained until free-standing UK legislation can be implemented.
As a priority, EU Regulations, which have direct effect in member states without the need for domestic legislation, will have to be replaced by UK law immediately on a Brexit. Examples include the General Data Protection Regulation, the Solvency II Delegated Regulation, and the Market Abuse Regulation. As a stop-gap, it may be necessary simply to provide that such Regulations continue to take effect as if they formed part of UK law.
In the longer term, where it is intended that domestic legislation should move away from the position previously required under EU law, that will need to be the subject of consultation and political debate. The details of financial services regulation are therefore likely to be vying for attention along with a great many other issues, many of which will carry much greater political significance.
A key question is: what will UK financial services legislation look like following Brexit? We think the answer is that it would look very similar to the way it does now. This is partly because a number of key European measures implement agreed international principles (such as Basel III and the IAIS Common Framework), which it seems reasonable to assume the UK would wish to continue to adhere to. In addition, the UK would no doubt wish to have equivalence status under Solvency II.
While some changes might occur at the margins, therefore, particularly given the willingness of the UK to gold-plate financial services directives in the past, there seems little reason to expect a bonfire of regulation immediately following a Brexit. And any settlement with the EU that permitted the continuation of trade on favourable terms would almost certainly bring with it a requirement to maintain at least broadly equivalent legal and regulatory regimes.
It is to be hoped that an exit agreement negotiated under Article 50 would address the position of existing rights in detail, as in the absence of such agreement the law is unclear. One can see arguments that existing or vested rights (such as the right of an EU citizen living and working in the UK pre-Brexit) should be retained following a Brexit. It is less clear whether a passporting right from the UK into the EU would similarly be capable of being regarded as being vested.
The position of firms in other EEA member states passporting into the UK is also unclear. Schedule 3 to FSMA can be read in a way which would mean that EEA firms exercising passporting rights into the UK pre-Brexit could continue to do so after the UK ceases to be a member state of the EU. In any case, that would clearly be something the UK could choose to allow explicitly. However, the working assumption as of now has to be that passporting rights, in both directions, will cease on Brexit.
With the uncertainty over the timing and the form of Brexit, precise legal steps are difficult to identify. However, we would recommend that, as a starting point, all businesses should try to identify the risks and opportunities associated with Brexit that they will face. These might include:
Having carried out this analysis, a number of steps may suggest themselves:
Finally, you should also think how you can best provide reassurance to clients, shareholders and employees that you have identified the issues and are on top of them, without hiding from the fact that there may well be significant challenges, and perhaps opportunities, ahead.
We have set up a Brexit Advisory Team to work closely with our many clients in the insurance sector to identify the issues and solutions to all aspects of the UK's future relationship with the EU, whatever form that may take. Please email email@example.com for more information.