Banking and finance dispute resolution
For the latest news and comment on banking and finance disputes.
For the latest news and comment on banking and finance disputes.
For all the latest news and comment in clinical negligence healthcare law
This collection looks at the latest news and comment on commercial contracting healthcare law. With the health and social care sector under…
For all the latest news and comment in employment and pensions healthcare law
For all the latest legal and regulatory news and comment in health technology
This collection contains DAC B eachcroft's latest report, The Route to Integrated Healthcare , which provides the first practical examples of how…
This collection looks at the latest strategic, commercial, regulatory and negligence legal and advisory news and comment in health and social care. …
For all the latest news and comment on employment and pensions law.
DAC Beachcroft Dublin specialises in insurance, professional indemnity, defendant personal injury, health, commercial litigation and employment work.…
For all the latest new and comment in tax law.
The GC Collective collection offers insight and comment for General Counsels (GCs) and in-house legal teams.
For the latest news and comment on Corporate, M&A and Equity Capital Markets.
Analysis, commentary and checklists on the legal and governance implications of Brexit on businesses operating in, and trading with, the UK
The Accountant's Liability Collection brings you topical news and insight of interest to accountants, actuaries, trustees and other financial…
Events and online training for the health and social care sector.
DAC Beachcroft's LatAm Quarterly Newsletter discusses topical news and issues in Latin America
In response to client suggestions and requests, DAC Beachcroft's insurance sector flagship publication.
For all the latest legal and regulatory news and comment in health and social care integration
For all the latest news and comment in corporate regulatory healthcare law
Find advice, commentary and thought leadership on all aspects of Director's & Officer's Insurance; from contract formation through to complex…
This collection looks at the latest news, comment and development on the law affecting mental health services. The law affecting mental health…
Our market-leading Information Law team regularly publish articles and updates addressing the ever-evolving Information Law landscape.
This collection looks at our Safety, Health and Environment Team and the products and services they can provide. In the climate of increased…
The Insurance Act 2015 comes into force in August 2016 and will represent a significant change to insurance contract law in this country. This…
Legislative changes are bringing major changes to the Insurance landscape. This collection houses DAC Beachcroft's alerts on the pertinent issues.
For all the latest news and comment in clinical regulatory healthcare law
Organisations face ever-increasing expectations from Government, regulators, customers or service users, and other stakeholders, so scrutiny and…
For all the latest legal and regulatory news and comment in healthcare estates and facilities management
This collection addresses the full spectrum of cyber security and data risk management – the zeitgeist of our age.
We have acted for clients in the majority of significant product liability cases that have been decided in the UK over the last 35 years. Our product…
Considering the future landscapes of our cities
The European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) came into force on 25 May 2016. A rewrite of European data protection law, the GDPR imposes…
Considering the future of housing
For the latest news and comment on public procurement law.
Welcome to the Construction Risks collection. This space is used to report upon issues of interest to those who seek to allocate, manage and reduce…
Technology, brands and intellectual capital are key assets for any successful business. Our intellectual property (IP) team are experts at helping…
Considering the future of retail
The Insurance Market Conditions and Trends report is DAC Beachcroft's insurance sector flagship publication. Now in its tenth year, the report…
The Solicitors' Risk Collection addresses issues and developments affecting legal practitioners, and the professional indemnity insurers of legal…
Published On: 11 February 2016
A recent decision of the Irish High Court (1 February 2016) to uphold the declinature of a claim made pursuant to a policy of "All Risks" Contractors Liability Insurance is of particular interest as very few matters concerning claims declined by insurers are heard by the Irish courts. The lack of Irish case law in this area can be a frustration for insurers in considering their options on foot of a declinature. The recent judgment in Kelly Builders Rosemont Limited v HCC Underwriting Agency Limited, in which DAC Beachcroft Dublin advised the Defendant insurers, may offer some clarity to insurers in this position.
Kelly Builders (Rosemont) Limited ("Kelly Builders"), a building contractor, had a policy of insurance with HCC Underwriting Agency Limited ("HCC") which included amongst other matters "hot works".
In November 2008, Kelly Builders were undertaking repair work to the roof of the student restaurant block at the National University of Ireland in Maynooth. During the course of these works a significant fire took place which resulted in the complete destruction of the building.
The policy of insurance included a condition precedent which stated: "The following must be kept available for immediate use near the scene of operations; (a) suitable and fully charged fire extinguishers."
The evidence demonstrated that the contractor who was working on the roof on behalf of Kelly Builders had only one fire extinguisher, and furthermore, when he had tried to use it, it had failed. In the circumstances HCC declined cover.
The declinature was challenged by Kelly Builders who issued specific performance proceedings in the Irish High Court. The matter ran for nine days before Ms Justice Murphy. Judge Murphy (in a 78 page written judgment) held that based on the facts and "on the balance of probabilities" Kelly Builders had not complied with the condition precedent, and specifically found they had not proven the fire extinguisher on the roof was 'suitable and fully charged'.
On this basis, the Court dismissed Kelly Builders claim for specific performance of the contract of insurance and its claim for all other ancillary reliefs.
Owing to the scarcity of Irish case law in this area, HCC relied on English authorities that are of "persuasive authority" in the Irish courts. It is a notable development that an Irish judgment now specifically recognises and endorses the principles set out in these decisions.
Cornhill Insurance plc v D.E Stamp Felt Roofing Contractors Limited  EWCA Civ 395, was cited throughout the judgment. As practitioners will be aware, this case is authority for the proposition that non-compliance with a condition precedent on the part of an insured will absolve the insurer of liability even if the non-compliance does not in any way cause the loss. Judge Murphy considered this principle to be directly applicable to the present case and was relied upon by HCC in defending its position.
Ms Justice Murphy acknowledged this proposition to be "an eminently logical one", and noted that "a condition precedent is one which must be complied with before the contractual obligation to indemnify takes effect. Thus, whether the compliance or non compliance leads to or affects in any way the event which gives rise to the requirement for indemnity is irrelevant."
Ms Justice Murphy further held that the Court, in this instance, "has not been pointed to any relevant authority in this jurisdiction which would suggest otherwise and on that basis, considers it appropriate to adopt the rationale of Longmore LJ in Cornhill Insurance plc v D.E Stamp Felt Roofing Contractors Limited."
This judgment will no doubt be of significant interest to insurers writing business in Ireland. In the absence of any specific judicial guidance on this point there has been some understandable concern to date for Irish insurers in relation to the options available to them in a declinature challenge situation. We consider this judgment will provide much needed clarity to enable full consideration of all the issues.
Kelly Builders claim for specific performance of the contract of insurance against HCC Underwriting Agency Limited was successfully defended by DAC Beachcroft Dublin.